before was now gone from the area.
Around 4:00 PM , Valerie managed to contact Stephanie Sprang’s live-in boyfriend, Ron Metcalf, and
they agreed to meet and check Tina’s residence. Ron lived with Stephanie on Magers
Drive, only a few houses down the road from Tina’s place. When Valerie got there,
she and Ron talked for a while, and then Valerie decided to enter the house. She removed
a rear window screen, raised a window and climbed through. Everything was very still,
quiet and spooky. Valerie went farther into the house, and what she saw terrified
her: there were bloodstains on the living room and hallway carpet, a lot of blood.
It looked as if someone had been dragged along the carpet. Valerie, now frantic, quickly
left the house and phoned the sheriff’s office once more.
Previously, the officers had been sent to do only “welfare checks,” but now it was
clear there was something seriously wrong at the house on King Beach Drive. This time,
when KCSO sergeants arrived at the residence, they were determined to go inside and
figure out just what had happened there.
TEN
A Chance Encounter
David Barber had been the sheriff of Knox County, Ohio, for eighteen years by November
2010. He was one of those guys who had come up through the ranks. Before becoming
sheriff, he’d been a uniformed deputy sheriff, a detective, a detective sergeant and
the lieutenant in charge of the detective division at the KCSO.
He’d won numerous awards over the years, including Ohio’s Distinguished Law Enforcement
Service Award in 1999. He was very proud of his office having received CALEA accreditation
in July 2007. CALEA stood for Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies,
which had been created in 1979 as a credentialing authority through the joint efforts
of law enforcement’s major executive associations. CALEA’s goals were to “strengthen
crime prevention and control capabilities, formalize essential management procedures,
and establish fair and nondiscriminatory personnel practices.” It was also to “solidify
interagency cooperation and coordination and increase community and staff confidence
in the agency.” In layman’s terms, being accredited by CALEA helped KCSO work more
smoothly with other law enforcement agencies in cases of an emergency where a lot
of police presence was needed.
Sheriff Barber had no idea on the morning of November 11, 2010, that in a very short
amount of time he and his office were going to need all the benefits CALEA accreditation
had to offer. All he knew then was that KCSO was the smallest sheriff’s office to
ever achieve CALEA standards.
Despite the sheriff’s rightful pride in the accreditation, he did not regularly need
to go outside his own department for help. Crime in Knox County was simply not prevalent.
In the preceding year there had been only one confirmed robbery, one stabbing, one
kidnapping case, and one homicide. Even the number of vehicle thefts had totaled only
thirty for the whole year.
* * *
Because of Valerie Haythorn’s initial phone call to KCSO, the first officer to have
had any contact with the King Beach Drive residence was Deputy Charles Statler of
KCSO’s Patrol Division.
The Patrol Division, headed by Captain David Shaffer and comprised of three sergeants
and eighteen deputies, was responsible for protecting the sixty thousand people in
the county, spread out over 525 square miles. Cities like Mount Vernon had their own
police departments, but all the rural areas, including Apple Valley, where Tina, Sarah,
Kody and Stephanie lived, were patrolled by KCSO units.
Because of the disturbing circumstances at the home on King Beach Drive, the matter
was taken on by the KCSO Detective Division. This division was headed by Lieutenant
Gary Rohler, and included Detective Sergeant Roger Brown, and Detectives Thomas Bumpus,
David Light and Doug Turpen. Prior to that