said.
âProbably not,â Shirley Mayer said.
âIâm a nontraditional student,â Brigitte blurted out.
âYes,â Shirley Mayer said, smiling. âThatâs admirable.â
On the drive home, Brigitte thought about how she didnât want Shirley Mayer to get fired, but how if it did happen, it would be Shirley Mayerâs own fault. She was pretty and charismatic and had seduced them all with her practical knowledge, thought-provoking exercises, and unfriendly demeanor.
On the first day of class, for example, she had offered a third of them chocolates from a huge Seeâs Candies assortment. She offered a second third of them chocolates as well, but this time from a somewhat less varied assortment containing only dark fruit creams. The students in the last third were offered a choice between marshmallow creams and toffees. Afterward, when Shirley Mayer asked them what they thought the exercise meant, they respondedâmouths fullâthat they didnât know. âYou,â she said then, pointing to Ely Gimble, who had been in the first third. âYou took forever to decide.â
Ely nodded. âAre there any fruit creams left?â he asked, and Shirley Mayer absently handed him the box.
âAnd you,â she said, pointing to Brigitte, who had been in the last third. âWhat was your experience?â
âI chose faster,â Brigitte said immediately, desperate even then to make an impression.
âThatâs right,â Shirley Mayer said, nodding. âAnd so my point is?â she asked, looking first to Brigitte, then to the rest of the class. Nobody said anything. âWhat about you?â she asked Paige Cox, who had been in the middle group. âState your name and describe your experience, please.â
âPaige. I donât like chocolate.â
âBut you picked one,â Shirley Mayer said.
âIâm going to give it to someone else,â Paige said. Then she added, âTo my girlfriend.â
Two boys in the back of the room giggled.
âWhatâs funny, guys?â Shirley Mayer asked them.
They sat up straight in their chairs and turned instantly, mockingly solemn. âUm,â Davis Bonaire said, âthat sheâs a lesbian?â
Everyone looked at Shirley Mayer, who they already knew to be gay. She paused briefly before saying, âTake out a sheet of paper, please.â
âWho, me?â Davis asked.
âYes, you,â Shirley said. âAnd your friend. Whatâs your name?â
âJojo,â Jojo Mankowski said.
âAnd you, Jojo. Take out a sheet of paper.â
The two boys shuffled their notebooks and came up with some paper. When they were ready, Shirley Mayer said, âNow, please write a hateful letter to Paige.â
âExcuse me?â Davis said.
âThis isnât high school, you know,â Jojo said. âWeâre paying for this class. If we want to be taught a lesson, weâll call our mothers.â
âLesson?â Shirley Mayer said. âWhat lesson? I would like you both to write a hateful letter to Paige, please, so I can get on with this lecture.â
Paige turned around then and looked at the two of them. âYeah,â she said. âWrite me a hateful letter.â
Davis and Jojo looked at each other. âI ainât doing that,â Davis said, laying his pen on the desk.
âMe neither,â Jojo said, copying Davis.
Shirley Mayer shrugged. âSuit yourselves,â she said. âJust trying to be accommodating.â
Paige turned back around then and smiled at Shirley Mayer, who ignored her. âNow,â Shirley Mayer said, âgetting back to the chocolate. What was the purpose?â
Jojo Mankowski raised his hand. âYes?â Shirley Mayer said, pointing to him.
âItâs easier to choose when youâve got less to choose from,â he said.
âGood man!â Shirley Mayer
Douglas E. Schoen, Melik Kaylan