to be the one to die?â
Dad stares at the woman and without hesitation responds, âHave you ever said to anybody something like âIf Iâm ever brain damaged and in a coma, just put me out of my misery?ââ
âWhat?â the woman asks, blinking nervously.
Dad presses on, âI mean, I think most people have said things like that. I know I have, and I know friends have said things like that to me. If you were unable to kill yourself but you wanted to be dead, donât you think youâd want somebody to know your wishes?â
Alice, pretending to be real concerned but actually sounding phony to me, says, âIâm not sure thatâs really the point, Syd. Weâre not here today to discuss voluntary euthanasia.â
Dad sighs and shakes his head. âYouâre right, Alice. Letâs keep that focus nice and tight. To answer your friendâs questionâwhat do I think about Detraux? I think he was a man who did what he thought he had to do.â
Alice looks at Dad and says, âI know youâve brought some video footage of interviews youâve been conducting with the child killerââ
âChild killer?â Dad interrupts.
Alice burrows in. âMr. Detraux did kill his son, didnât he?â she asks. âHe was convicted of murder for that crime, wasnât he? His little boy was a two-year-old, utterly incapable of defending himself in any way, wasnât he?â Alice sounds confident.
Suddenly a photograph of a cute little boy, a blowup of a snapshot, grainy, a kind of orange tint over the color, fills the screen.
Alice says, âWeâre showing our audience a snapshot of little Colin right now.â
The audience ooh s and ahh s for a moment, then snaps to silence as they realize this was Earl Detrauxâs victim.
Alice, certain that nothing can go wrong, asks, âEarl did kill this little angel, didnât he?â
Dad looks at her and quietly says, âNo, he didnât.â
Alice looks genuinely confused, almost stunned. âThat is Colin Detraux, isnât it?â
Dad answers, âYes, that was him.â
â Was , because his father murdered him.â
âNo,â Dad answers. âColin died from a terrible, terminal, inoperable seizure disorder, an irreversible medical condition, coupled with profound mental retardation that made his existence insufferable.â
âHis fatherââ Alice begins, but Dad cuts her off.
âHis father loved him enough to do whatever he had to do to end his sonâs suffering. Earl loved his son enough to sacrifice his own life to end his childâs painââ
âIncluding murder,â Alice interrupts.
âWhy donât we let Earl speak for himself?â Dad asks softly.
âIndeed,â Alice says. âAre we ready to roll the tape?â A couple seconds later, Alice says, âWe are? Good. Roll please.â
On the screen appears an image of Earl Detraux. I have seen him before, but I am curious about his appearance now, since heâs been in prison. Luckily my eyes are focused on him. He is sitting in front of a gray wall, in an orange-colored inmateâs jumpsuit. I canât tell how tall he is, but he looks about the same size as Dad. His face is pleasant. His hair is cut quite short and heâs mostly bald on top. His left ear sticks out a little farther than the right. Otherwise heâs regular-looking with a mild, gap-toothed smile. He sure doesnât look like any murderer Iâve ever seen in movies or on TV crime shows. Just the oppositeâhe looks like a next-door neighbor, a guy youâd see out mowing his lawn or raking his leaves, Mr. Average.
The way the prison room is set up, Dad is sitting next to Earl; their metal folding chairs almost touch, but both men face more toward the camera than toward one another. They are framed on-screen from the ankles up. They look
Glenn Stout
Stephanie Bolster
F. Leonora Solomon
Phil Rossi
Eric Schlosser
Melissa West
Meg Harris
D. L. Harrison
Dawn Halliday
Jayne Ann Krentz