returned to my seat, the cushy recliner opposite Dr. P.
âLook, it doesnât matter who I hang out with. Iâm lying to them. All of them. And the more we hang out and talk, the more people seem to like meâI mean, the me they think I am.â
âYou donât like lying?â
I thought about that for a minute. I knew lying was wrong. Immoral even. But I was doing it for the best of reasons. It was so easy to believe that made it right.
âI do and I donât.â I spread out my hands. âSee, the thing is itâs working . All that crap didnât follow us to this town. I donât worry about my mother out alone or about my father losing business or Jack Murphy ringing the doorbell to bury a bullet in my brain.â
âDan, youâre not a good bad person and youâre not even a bad good person. Youâre normal, flawed just like everybody else. Does that make sense?â
Kenny groaned in my mind.
She shifted in her chair, crossed her legs, adjusted her glasses.
She waited a moment and asked, âDan, what do you think makes a person good?â
Her voice held no humor, though she still smiled. I wasnât sure where she was going with this, but I propped my ankle on my knee and thought about it. My motherâshe was good. My dad. Brandon. They were all good.
âGood people,â I began, âdo good things. Bad people do bad things.â
An eyebrow arched at me, and Dr. Philips angled her head. âThatâs very simplistic, donât you think?â
I lifted a shoulder. It wasnât simple, not at all. âIt should be.â
Dr. Philips waved her hand, indicating I should continue. âTell meâ¦whatâs an example of a bad thing?â
Without hesitation, I replied, âKilling someone.â
âOkay, now letâs consider the reverse, say, the driver of a car involved in an accident that kills his passenger. Is he now a bad person because of this?â
âWell, no, of course not, butââ
âWhat about if that driver had, say, fallen asleep at the wheel? Is he bad now?â
Yes! He should have stopped at a motel if he was so tired. Well, wait. Maybe he didnât realize how tired he was. Hell. âHe made a mistake.â
Dr. P. pointed a finger at me. âYou got it. He made a mistake. It doesnât mean heâs a bad person.â
My temper surged at the moralizing tone in her words. âOkay, look. I know where youâre going with this.â I waved my hands. âEverybody makes mistakes. Yes, sometimes killing someone isnât bad. Doesnât make it good either.â
Dr. Philips nodded.
âDan, people arenât just good or just bad at their most fundamental level. Everybody, every one of us, has the potential for both.â
Oh.
Hell no.
Thisâ¦this wasnât what I wanted to hear. I slumped lower in my seat. I couldnât look at Dr. P. I knew there was bad in me, had known it for years. I could see it, and its name was Kenny. And that was why I kept him a secret. When she gasped and uncrossed her legs to lean toward me and take my hand, I sort of had to look at her. âI think youâve misunderstood me, Dan. Iâm saying youâre not bad and never were. You did something that wasnât so nice, but neither was it evil, so I wonder why you persist in believing yourself to be.â
Her words and the Hallmark tone that carried them twisted my lips into a sneer. âNot so nice? Really? Dr. Philips, the judge didnât sentence me to nine months in juvenile detention because I broke the ânot so niceâ law. He did it because I did something soâ¦despicable,â I said as my sneer spread. âHe wanted me off the streets to protect people.â
Dr. Philips peered over her glasses and smiled. âAgain, overly simplistic. Dan, the truth is the crime you committed was malicious and you deserved to be punished,â she
Melissa McClone, Robin Lee Hatcher, Kathryn Springer
Kendel Lynn, Gigi Pandian, Diane Vallere