you to lunch.â
âMe? Iâm more than a quarter-century older than you. I know that anything goes nowadays, but this is more than I expected.â
âMrs. Rabinowitz, I donât know that I could keep up with you.â
âI bet you could. But meantime, what do you really want?â
âTo take you to lunch.â
âUh-huh.â
âAnd talk to you about the department.â
âYou mean about poor Nathaniel.â
âYes.â
âYou a reporter?â
âNo. No, Iâm not.â
âWho are you then?â
âIâm an investigator,â I said. âIâm working for Ahmad Nazamiâs defense.â
âShow me. You got ID?â
âYes. I do,â I said and showed her my PI license.
âOkay, whatâs your name again? Carl?â
âYes. Carl.â
âYou can take me to lunch, and you can call me Esther. It was nice, bringing me the plant. Nathaniel always used to bring me chocolates. For my birthday. He always got the date wrong, but he always brought them. Really, really good ones. You could put on five pounds just holding the box.â
Â
âNate was my favorite,â she said over a bowl of pea soup.
âWhyâs that?â
âAt least you could understand him. These others . . . listen, do you know philosophy?â She was spooning the chunks of ham out of the bowl.
âAre you doing that because youâre kosher?â
âNah, Iâm a vegetarian.â
âOh,â I said.
âBut not a religious one. I donât mind a little meat should touch my food, infuse it with flavor. Thomas Jefferson was like that. I just do it for my health. I want to live forever. I have grandchildren. You want to see pictures?â
âOf course,â I said.
She took a packet of photos out of her pocket book. âMy daughter-in-law, an angel, e-mails me pictures every day.â I accepted them and made the appropriate cooing sounds of admiration. âI print them out myself,â she explained. âSometimes I Photoshop them, improve them a little.â
âHow adorable,â I said. âSo, tell me about Nate.â
âOh, oh, oh, poor Nathaniel. What a nice man. So much fun. We used to laugh. Who would want to kill such a man. Hah! As if I didnât know.â
âLike who?â
âDonât be so quick Mr. Investigator, Carl. I use it as a turn of phrase. In the circumstances, I shouldnât.â
âWhat about Ahmad?â
âAhmad? Kill somebody? Why do you think Iâm sitting here talking to you? If I thought it was Ahmad, I would say, Go away. Leave me alone. They got the killer.â
âNot Ahmad, then?â
âNo. No, he and Nate were friends. Oh, how they used to argue.â
âThey argued? But you said they were friends.â
âOh, goyim. What are you, Irish?â
âNo.â
âMy late husband was Irish. Nice man. But his idea of an argument was to step outside and start punching someone. Argue, like philosophers. For them, thatâs like the joy of sex. For most of them. But there are some, they get so serious . . . factions, worse than Trotskyites. You donât know philosophy, do you?â
âNo.â
âNobody does. Iâll give you a quick overview from the perspective of the departmental secretary and a grandmother who had a very
fine education herself at the City College of New York, back when it was one of the best schools in the country, almost as hard to get into as your Ivy League schools. And it was free. We all think weâve come so far, but when I was growing up, an education, a fine college education, was free.
âAnyway, there are two main groups. They call themselves continental and analytic. Are you ready? You might want to take notes. This is going to be on the test.
ââAnalytic philosophers want to say only what they can be absolutely, logically certain about.
Giuliana Rancic
Bella Love-Wins, Bella Wild
Faye Avalon
Brenda Novak
Iain Lawrence
Lynne Marshall
Anderson Atlas
Cheyenne McCray
Beth Kery
Reginald Hill