remembered Morgan. âDarling, I know I have no right to come into your life and start trying to call the shots, but I have to state this again. I donât think Nigel killed that woman, and unless heâs convicted or decides he doesnât need us, heâs my number-one priority while in Mulligan.â Oliver wanted to put his hand out to touch hers, to show her that she should trust him. To show that even though Nigel was his top priority, he still cared for her. Even though he shouldnât.
Darling, to his surprise, seemed to choose her next words carefully.
âI understand,â she said in almost a whisper. âBut, tell me, why are you so sure that heâs innocent?â
âThe surprise on his face when he found out about the body,â he answered.
Darling huffed. âSurprise can be faked, Oliver. I do it every Christmas when Trudy gives me a can of peanut brittle wrapped in reindeer-decorated paper.â
âTrue, he could have faked the surprise,â he conceded. âBut not the pain.â Oliver replayed the moment when heâd watched as the cops had told the wealthy man about the body. He didnât need to hear the manâs response to know it had caught him completely by surprise...and hurt him.
Darling hesitated, brows pulling together, but she didnât have time to respond. Her phone blared to life, a cute jingle that felt out of place within the conversation. She let out a long sigh as she read the ID.
âExcuse me a second,â she said, standing.
âNo problem.â
Oliver was able to drink the rest of his neglected coffee, pairing it with one of Darlingâs chocolate-covered circles of delicious sin, before the private investigator came back. The look on her face made him stand.
âWhatâs wrong?â
Darling bit her lip. âDo you want a list or a long-winded sentence?â It was a less-than-halfhearted attempt to lighten whatever mood had erupted around her. Oliver answered with an equal lack of mirth.
âList.â
âOne, the medical examiner believes our Jane Doe was killed yesterday morning,â she ticked off. âTwo, that puts Nigel in the clear since he was apparently eating breakfast with your team while you were bailing me out.â Oliver wanted to feel relief at her wordsâthat he had been right about Nigelâs innocenceâbut Darlingâs grim expression had every part of him on guard. âThree, they havenât been able to identify the woman yet.â There was a hesitation after the words left her mouth.
âCouldnât Nigel identify her? If he met with her he had to know her.â
She held up four fingers. âFour, Nigel is denying that he was ever even at the hotel, let alone in Mulligan, last night. No one has stepped forward to prove otherwise, and itâs Nigelâs word against Danâs. There are no security cameras at the hotel, either. None that work properly, at least.â
Oliverâs instinct was to question Danâs claim of seeing Nigel in the first place, but he felt an irrational loyalty to him, because it was obvious that was how Darling felt about him.
âI donât think prints take that long to process,â he said instead. âSurely theyâll figure out who she is within the week and go from there.â
Darlingâs face darkened. She held up her hand. âFive,â she said, voice shaking despite her calm exterior, âall of her fingers and teeth are missing. Someone removed them.â
Chapter Six
Any chance of normal conversation disappeared at the grim news.
âRemoved?â Oliver repeated.
Darling let her hand drop to her side and settled back behind her desk. Her half-eaten donut wasnât as appealing as it had been minutes before.
âPostmortem, but yes,â she confirmed.
Oliver also sat back down, though he didnât relax.
âWho told you all this?â
âDerrick,â
Gil Brewer
Raye Morgan
Rain Oxford
Christopher Smith
Cleo Peitsche
Antara Mann
Toria Lyons
Mairead Tuohy Duffy
Hilary Norman
Patricia Highsmith