frustrations of the profession.
David Rooney: I fell into journalism almost accidentally. I studied film and had a lifetime interest in theater. During my high school years in Australia, I got involved with theater companies. I flirted with the idea of becoming an actor, but I made bad choices with my audition pieces for the National Institute of Dramatic Art. Everybody said, “Don’t do Tennessee Williams,” and I did Tom in The Glass Menagerie . Everybody said, “For your Shakespeare piece, don’t do Romeo,” which is exactly what I did. It wasn’t to be, and now I’m relieved that it didn’t happen. It’s too much of a struggle.
When I first left Australia, I traveled around the United States for a year. I spent six months in New York and discovered the city’s wonderful theater landscape. Then I moved to Europe and spent 20 years there. I had friends working in theater, so I saw pretty much everything in the West End and beyond. I came to New York once a year during those two decades and caught as much as I could.
After I moved to Italy in 1990, I started working for Variety as a freelancer. I took over as the Rome bureau chief in 1993. I had little journalistic experience prior to that. I had written a handful of book reviews for Time Out while I was in London and some pieces for an Australian independent film publication. I started covering European and North American film festivals. After 14 years there, I was looking to leave Italy, and Peter Bart, the editor-in-chief at Variety at the time, offered me a transfer to New York as a film reporter and reviewer. A year later, Charles Isherwood left Variety to go to the New York Times . Peter knew I had a passionate interest in theater and liked my reviewing style, so I became the chief theater critic and theater editor.
David Cote: I was an actor doing experimental plays at venues such as La MaMa, P.S. 122, and the Ontological-Hysteric Theater at St. Mark’s Church. While I was doing that, I became angry about the lack of media coverage of Off Off Broadway, so I co-founded a self-produced pre-blog called OFF . That was in 1996. It was basically manifests and reviews, photocopied and stapled and left for free at downtown theaters. In 2000, a position opened up at Time Out New York for a theater writer. Jason Zinoman knew me from Off Off Broadway, and that’s how he contacted me. I had never written a formal theater review before. I learned the journalism ropes at Time Out .
David Sheward: I wanted to be an actor, so I got a job at Backstage , thinking that I could find out about audition notices. I started doing reviews there, and then I became an editor, and that gradually became the focus on my attention. I was at Backstage for over 20 years.
Michael Dale: I became a critic totally by accident. About three months after starting a blog about attending theater, I got an email from the editor-in-chief of a brand new web site, BroadwayWorld.com . He offered me the chance to write about pretty much whatever I wanted. I started writing humorous essays, but then we started getting invited to review Off Off Broadway plays. I had never thought much about reviewing, but I started taking assignments. Eventually, the website was accepted by the Broadway League’s press list, and I was named chief critic.
Zachary Stewart: I really did just fall into it. When I began working as the listings editor at TheaterMania.com in 2008 I would request to review shows I was interested in but weren’t being covered by any of the regular reviewers (stuff like haunted houses, novelty gay musicals, and Off Off Off Broadway). By 2012, I started reviewing four or five shows a month. And in 2013, I became the chief critic at TheaterMania .
I had previously directed several shows in the city, and I never really had any intention of becoming a critic, but I’ve discovered that I like being a part of the conversation without having to make the personal sacrifices (lots of travel,
Melissa Giorgio
Max McCoy
Lewis Buzbee
Avery Flynn
Heather Rainier
Laura Scott
Vivian Wood, Amelie Hunt
Morag Joss
Peter Watson
Kathryn Fox