assistant housekeeper to her mother. A friendship with young Oswyn developed into a clandestine relationship and by the time her mother knew of this secret love affair, her beautiful young daughter was pregnant. She explained to Alice her relation to young Oswyn and how the baby's father would have to be kept secret even from the members of the household. It was to protect young Oswyn that Alice coaxed the young farmhand to her bed, so he would now be the source of whispering by the staff.” Vera continued. “Oswyn saw them in bed. She may have arranged it so to help break their relationship. He confronted her in the library next day. The library was on the top floor and a stairs led out onto the flat roof above. It was here that they had spent many an hour on hot summer evenings making love beneath a canopy of stars, shamelessly naked in the moonlight. He followed her out onto the roof. The conversation that followed was supposedly overheard by a staff member who remained nameless. She told him all her mother had related to her. Upset, he held her by the shoulders and shook her. ‘This must be a lie contrived to break up their relationship. I don’t believe you.” “But my mother wouldn’t lie to me about something like that.” He felt his pride draining from him, this wonderful world of love and lust was suddenly taken from his life. He pulled her close to him. “No.” she shouted and as she pushed him away, she stumbled backwards, her lower limbs catching the wall of the parapet and she went toppling over. His mind took on a hazy blankness for how long he didn’t know. Until the commotion below, the anguish of crying and screams of shock brought him to his senses. He left the house and went wandering through the woods. After Vera had finished her account they left the restaurant and Henry walked her back to the shipping office and then headed for Scotland Yard. He was hoping Vincent might have the file on the Oswyn Welland case. He thought there might be a lot more that Vera hadn’t told him. He climbed two flights of stairs to Vincent's office. It was a small room tucked away at the back of the building with an unremarkable view of a drab office block. He knocked and walked in. Vincent was reclining in a leather armchair alongside the open window dozing fitfully. Henry coughed loudly, waking him with a start. “You could give a man a heart attack doing things like that!” “Sorry to disturb your siesta.” “You’re forgiven, but you must realize,” he said jocularly, “us old retired chaps need our little afternoon nap.” “I thought I’d drop by and say hello. I know it’s a bit soon to expect any developments from Tom, but would you think there is any chance of seeing the file on the Oswyn Welland case?” Vincent tapped a red folder lying on the desk. “Here it is. I’ve been going through it since early morning and cannot see anything that could connect it to your Shirley’s murder. Now I’d like you to study it and see can you come up with anything I might have missed.” He handed the file to Henry and stood up stretching himself. “I’m going out for a little constitutional stroll, will be about an hour; would you like me to send you up a cup of coffee or tea?” “No thanks, I’ve only just had lunch.” It wasn’t a large file and it took Henry less than half an hour to read through it thoroughly. There was nothing he could find even if it were proved Oswyn had pushed her, to connect this to Shirley's murder. Alice Whittle had been in the early stages of pregnancy according to the autopsy report. She had fallen onto railings and suffered terrible injuries, but nothing to suggest they were anything similar to the injuries on Shirley’s body. The verdict was accidental death through misadventure. This is amazing how it could have suggested she might have been climbing around the roof parapet and fallen off. My goodness he thought as he closed the file, some of