up.â
âI think you should leave, Arthur. I need to get some ice for James, but Iâm not going to do that until you leave because Iâm not going to leave you alone with him.â The looks were looks she had been giving since she was a child, but they had always been directed at Paul or my mother. The calm, articulate strength was new, if unsurprising.
âHe was trying to rape you.â
âNo, I wasnât, you idiot,â James said, holding his bleeding nose.
âHe wasnât.â Emily sat up straight. Her shirt was still unbuttoned and her bra cup, though it covered her nipple and areola, was twisted. She looked, unquestionably, like a sexually competent woman. But looks can be deceiving, and Hickham had once said that he had no desire to have sex with a woman whom he wasnât raping.
I looked at her, trying to be sympathetic and caring.
âEmily,â I said. âWe told each other that we would never deny the truth. Right? And the truth is that he was trying to rape you.â
âThe truth is that heâs my boyfriend.â
âHeâs your boyfriend? But he doesnât respect women.â
âArthur. Weâve been going together for three months and this is the first time heâs tried to touch my breasts. Heâs a gentleman. You, on the other hand, are just like Paul.â
I was shocked that she would actually say this out loud. I stood up, finding that my knee hurt very badly.
âYouâd probably like it if I killed myself like Paul.â
This was an immensely petulant, manipulative, and self-pitying thing to say. Itâand Iâdeserved her contempt. What it and I got was something else.
Her face crumpled into a helpless sobbing that made her look five years old again. âIâm sorry,â she said. âArthur, Iâm so sorry. I never should have said that. Youâre nothing like Paul.â
â I wouldnât mind it if you killed yourself,â Hickham said.
âJames!â she said, and slapped him across his cheek.
âOw!â
Shame started to set in, and I said that I should probably go.
âYou should stay. James should go.â
But I was already on my way out.
f
The incident left me so unhappy that I took a cab back to Grand Central and got on the next train to New Haven. I realized fully that I had overreacted, and that Hickham had unquestionably been the victim of the afternoon. If anything, I was more clearly guilty of assault than Paul had ever been, at least until that day on the beach. When I got back to my dorm I knew I should call Emily and apologize, but I was embarrassed about my behavior. I hardly got any sleep that night, because I kept thinking about what I had seen and what I had done. I was going to call Emily the next morning, but then I didnât, and a couple more days went by and I still didnât call her. I found it difficult to concentrate on schoolwork, so mostly I did a lot of wandering around campus, thinking of everything and nothing. She called several times and left messages with the guys who lived on my hall, prompting them to tease me a bit. Sounds like sheâs got it bad for you, that sort of thing. Finally I called her back, and the first thing she told me was that she had broken up with James Hickham.
âGet back together with him,â I said. âI had no right toâ¦interrupt you.â
âNo. You were right all along about James. Only an unredeemable prick would tell someone to kill himself. Of course I should have known he was a prick, since he talks all the time about how women want to be raped. Just like you said. Iâm so stupid.â
âYouâre not stupid. Youâre the furthest thing from stupid.â
âWhat I said was stupid. Nobody has ever said anything stupider than that thing I said. Promise you forgive me?â
âOf course. And Iâm sorâ¦â
âListen, Iâm going to tell
Jane Costello
Neil Gaiman
G. Michael Hopf
Laura Anne Gilman
Janelle Stalder
Stephanie Rowe
Leo Tolstoy
Kelli Wolfe
Alex Apostol
Kennedy Layne