here?â she said.
âThe answers â theyâre here. They must be.â
âWhy?â
âYou, Catherine, this house, that night ⦠Itâs all here. Isnât it? We were here â â
âHow long have you known?â Frances interrupted.
âThat Iâm Emma?â I said.
Frances nodded.
âIâve always known that Iâm Emma,â I said. âBut I hadnât remembered about Catherine. Not until this week. Not until I saw you in the hospital. We were there, werenât we? Both of us, that night?â I said. âI ⦠I just had to speak to you. Since I saw you in the hospital Iâve been remembering things, things I havenât remembered before. I have no one else to talk to. There is no one I can tell.â
Frances continued to look at me. She was searching me with her eyes, and even though I didnât like it â how it made me feel â I let her, because I was desperate for her to let me stay and talk.
âI donât know why I should believe you,â she said.
âBecause you have to!â I said, my voice getting louder. âBecause there is no explanation for what I know â â
âThere are no explanations,â Frances said. âNone! Iâve been searching for an explanation. Iâve been waiting for a reason, an understanding, an answer why she died. Iâve been asking for a sign, for something â anything â to come to me through every day of every one of the long, long years since she died. And there has been nothing.â
âMaybe I know things you donâtâ¦?â I said.
âI doubt that,â she said.
âI have memories, images, inside my head â â
âI have those too, Ana.â
âBut they wonât be the same. I was with her, wasnât I? Before she died?â
âYou were,â Frances said slowly, looking at me again. âSo you remember that?â
I nodded.
âWould you talk to me?â I said. âPlease. Could you do that?â
There was another silence between us.
âWe arenât the same â you and I,â Frances said. âWhat you did sets you apart. If I agree to talk, you must never forget that.â And she looked at me in a way that made me cold, all over. I could feel my skin rippling with the chill.
I shivered. And I opened my mouth to speak â
âWhat I want to know,â she said, âis why you are here.â
I shook my head. âI donât know.â
âSo what do you know? It seems to me the answer is not very much, young Ana.â
âI need you, Frances. To help me,â I cried.
âAh!â she said. âHelp!â And her voice was getting louder now. âWhere was my help when I needed it?â
âMaybe ⦠maybe,â I said, stuttering, âmaybe itâs me? Maybe Iâm here, now, to help, to help you ⦠to help you understandâ¦â
Could it be that Iâd come back to make things better? I didnât know, but I grasped on to any reason I could find if it meant that Frances would keep talking to me.
âBut you canât change what happened, can you? You might have come back, Ana â Emma â whoever you are. But Catherine. Sheâs never coming back. Is she?â Her voice was low, controlled, challenging me.
âNo,â I said quietly. âI donât think so.â
âNothing will bring my Catherine back,â she said, her voice rising again, angry. âDonât you see? Nothing! And yet you â you are here.â
âI know,â I said. âIâm sorry.â I could feel tears welling in my throat.
âThere must be a reason!â she said again. âI want a reason!â
âI â I canât explain it,â I said. âI â I just feel so bad â Iâ¦â And the black, black feeling was rising up inside me.
It filled
Kelly Elliott
Patricia Pellicane
Emma Lai
Jessica Burkhart
Paula Marshall
Roderic Jeffries
Jessica Love
Joseph Lewis
Anonymous
Christina Henry