sang âMaybeâ to all the women who longed to participate in rock, and by doing so, opened a giant door for them. The strength of Smithâs attack inspired all the great girl-group singers and sounds that followed. Even the nerviest of singers, Janis Joplin, couldnât resist it: when she set loose her cosmic growl on the song in 1969 (on her second release, I Got Dem Olâ Kozmic Blues Again, Mama! ), the original Chantels record bubbled back up to number 113.
The Chantels followed âMaybeâ with four more hits in the next eighteen months (âEvery Night,â âI Love You,â âSummerâs Love,â and âLook in My Eyesâ), creating the first female doo-wop dynasty, delineating the transition between doo-wop and girl groups. The Bobettes may have scored with âMr. Leeâ a month before the Chantels, but they never hit the Top 40 again. Even the genteel Chordettes began to bear the Chantel influence. In 1959, they covered Leiber and Stollerâs âCharlie Brown,â the Coastersâ hit, and also Phil Spectorâs âTo Know Him Is to Love Him.â (Spector assembled the Chordettes compilation Mainly Rock âNâ Roll in 1990 for Ace.)
With Arlene Smith, the Chantels had achieved a sound to go along with their concept, and they were held in the same high esteem as any other male doo-wop group of the time. Smith was to women what Frankie Lymon was to preteens, a symbol of possibility that dissolved barriers. (And Smith is analogous to Tina Turner in the way both women transcended their typically male genres.) So the Chantels were not just standout doo-woppers for being femaleâthey were the beginning of girl groups. In April 1958, less than three months after âMaybe,â the Shirelles scored with âI Met Him on a Sunday,â and the girl-group era had begun. By 1960, when Ike and Tina Turner released âA Fool in Love,â Presleyâs great gender realignment suddenly suggested new possibilities for women. Even when singing about disappointment and betrayal, as Tina did, the overall effect was exultant.
*Â Â Â *Â Â Â *
The great myth of girl groups is that these acts were unilaterally conceived according to a dated sexist code of women attending to hairdos and dress while men controlled the song choices, production, arrangements, and management. This simplification rivals the false truism that rock ânâ roll is simply white people getting rich off black R&B styles. If girl groups were simply stooges propped up by male producers, thereâs no way weâd still be listening to âBe My Baby,â âWalking in the Rain,â âLeader of the Pack,â âUptown,â âDa Doo Ron Ron,â and âPlease Mr. Postman.â These songs and others like them transcend that myth, and remain regular buttons on oldies radio rotation. And there are so many other deserving girl-group records that radio has all but forgotten: not just lesser-known numbers by hitmakers (like âGirls Grow Up Faster Than Boysâ or âDonât Say Nothinâ Bad About My Babyâ by the Cookies, âFoolish Little Girlâ or âDonât Say Goodnight and Mean Goodbyeâ by the Shirelles, or âSweet Talkinâ Guy,â by the Chiffons) but lesser-known-gems by never-weres (âMr. Heartbreakâ by Cathy Saint or âYou Donât Have to Be a Baby to Cryâ by the Caravelles).
In fact, girl groups often relied on female songwriters (Carole King, Ellie Greenwich) and managers (the Shirellesâ Florence Greenberg), even when produced by the most controlling of men (Goldner, Spector). By 1962, Bo Diddleyâs touring band featured Norma Jean Wafford, âthe Duchess,â on guitar and vocals. Bassist Carol Faye played on most of Phil Spectorâs Gold Star sessions for the Crystals, the Ronettes, and the Righteous Brothers. Deborah Chessler
Linda Howard
Tanya Michaels
Minnette Meador
Terry Brooks
Leah Clifford
R. T. Raichev
Jane Kurtz
JEAN AVERY BROWN
Delphine Dryden
Nina Pierce