in disbelief. At that moment, her immediate and entire future had consisted of nothing more than the ceremonial burning of her tragic dress.
âThe event itself, tasteful,â Garth continued. âThe after-party, bumping. Iâm talking Phish. Or a Phish cover band. Or whatever the kids are listening to in . . .â He paused to silently calculate. â . . . in 2013. Because thatâs how this family parties.â He was still talking about the bar mitzvah.
âThank you for a lovely evening,â Claudia intoned. With no idea what else to do, she reached out and squeezed Garthâs shoulder, then turned and began, very slowly, to flee. Sheâd known it was rude.
âDonât walk away, Renee!
â Garth cried, quoting pop lyrics of a bygone era, and loudly. Claudia ignored him with remarkable ease as the nighttime crowd of concertgoers buoyed her along Prospect Park West.
âYou wonât see me follow you back home!â
Garth hollered after her. Claudia considered turning around to offer Garth a very human shrug that would communicate her heartfelt appreciation and regret. âI always thought that was a Steely Dan song, but itâs not! Itâs Left Banke!â Garth continued at top volume. âBanke! With an
e!
â
But Claudia
did
just walk away.
Over the next few weeks, Garth left several messages on Claudiaâs answering machine, but sheâd never gotten to the meat, erasing them as soon as sheâd heard: âHey. Itâs me.â
All of that had been last July.
One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, tenâtwo hundred bucks. Claudia couldnât see the bills themselves, just the relaxed movement of Garthâs shoulders as he caught the money and secured it with a clip that he jammed in the front pocket of his corduroys. Claudia worried that Garth would notice her and say hello. Simultaneously, she hoped that in the five months since theyâd last seen each other he might have forgotten theyâd ever met. Garthâs eyes immediately lit on Claudia and brightened. He wasnât angry, just hopeful. He ambled over, bowlegged.
âWill you look who the cat drug in!â Garth bellowed, his headphones still on.
âBoy, thatâs loud,â said Phoebe.
Garth pushed his headphones up. They leaked music, making a halo of hip-hop around his head. âWow. You are so gorgeous right now with your pink cheeks.â Claudia noticed Garthâs eyes, Siberian husky bright and pale, and his chapped lips, shiny with goo. âYouâre like Sabrina from
Charlieâs Angels
meets Rhoda,â he praised.
âNo, Iâm not,â said Claudia.
Garth gave Phoebe a polite, disinterested smile. âAnd who are
you?
â
âPhoebe,â said Phoebe.
âMy sister,â Claudia explained, adding pointedly, âsheâs sixteen.â
âCool.â But Garth clearly wasnât interested in Phoebe. Penetratingly, he admired Claudia. âSo how are two sophisticated Jewesses celebrating Christmas Eve?â
âWeâre headed uptown to my roommateâs parentsâ house,â Claudia told Garth.
âEast or west?â
âSide?â
âWhat else?â
âWest. Eighty-First and the Park.â
âPicturing that,â said Garth. âMe and my pop, we do the moviesâChinese food thing. In a strange twist, on Christmas Day we do movies and Vietnamese. You guys wanna come?â Garth scanned the sistersâ faces hopefully. âThe pork chops on Bayard Street are crazy good, and as we all know, Jews love swine.â
âI donât think so,â said Claudia.
âDonât think,
feel,
â Garth urged. âThatâs what went wrong last time.â
âMaybe next time.â
âBut next time is a year from now.â
âBy then weâll have so much to catch up on,â said Claudia.
Garth smiled and slid
Anne Conley
Robert T. Jeschonek
Chris Lynch
Jessica Morrison
Sally Beauman
Debbie Macomber
Jeanne Bannon
Carla Kelly
Fiona Quinn
Paul Henke