said, âis it true that approximately onemonth before the crime you and your brother attended a Fourth of July party?â
âThat is correct,â Nellie said, a worried look crossing her face.
Myers glanced at Nick, obviously unsure of what was coming. Nick kept his eyes on his sister, but Joe could see Nickâs fist was clenched.
âAnd I believe,â Daggett said to Nellie, âKaren Lee was also at this party, wasnât she?â
âYes, she was,â Nellie said quietly.
Frank noticed Karen Lee sitting nearby. She was nervously fingering her silky hair.
âTell me,â Daggett said, standing near Nellie. âAt this party, did you happen to witness an argument between your brother and Miss Lee?â
âObjection,â Myers said. âThis has noââ
âOverruled,â the judge cut in. âMiss Rodriguez, answer the question, please.â
âYes,â Nellie said. âI witnessed an argument between my brother and Miss Lee at this party.â
âWhat was this argument about?â Daggett asked.
âKaren had broken off her engagement to my brother a month before this party, and he was still upset about it,â Nellie explained, shifting in her chair.
âI understand there were some real fireworks that night,â Daggett said with a sly smile. âAnd Idonât mean in the sky. Tell me, did your brother become angry during this argument?â
âPeople often get angry during arguments,â Nellie said, struggling to stay composed.
âJust answer the question, please,â Daggett insisted.
âYes, he became angry,â Nellie admitted.
âDid he yell at Miss Lee?â Daggett asked.
âYes, he raised his voice a bit,â Nellie said. Joe could see that she was growing irritated with the prosecutor.
âAnd did he make an especially threatening comment to Miss Lee?â Daggett asked, fixing her cold eyes on Nellie. âA comment that was overheard by a number of the people present?â
âYes,â Nellie snapped, âbut it was merely a figure of speech. He didnât meanââ
âWhat was that comment?â Daggett said firmly.
Nellie hesitatedâas if she was afraid to answer, Frank thought.
âI will remind you,â Daggett told Nellie, âthat you have sworn to tell the whole truth up here. Failure to do so would be a criminal act.â
Nellie took a deep breath, then answered the question. âMy brother said, âKaren, sometimes you make me so mad I want to kill you.â â
Cries and whispers resounded throughout the room. As the judge banged his gavel for order, Frank glanced at the jury box. Just about everymember of the jury was staring harshly at Nick Rodriguez.
âNo further questions,â Daggett said, returning to her table with a satisfied expression.
âYeah, Daggettâs good,â Frank said after a sigh. âSo much for Nellieâs excellent impression.â
Knowing they had better get back to work, the Hardys left the courthouse and walked to a small park across the street. The day had warmed a bit, but a gray pall darkened the sky, as if reflecting the trialâs grim turn of events.
âI doubt Nick really meant what he said at that party,â Joe said as he and Frank sat on a bench, âbut Daggett sure made it seem as if he did. And it doesnât help that this information came from the mouth of Nickâs own twin sister.â
âAt this point,â Frank said, âit may not be enough for us to come up with evidence suggesting someone else might have done the crime. After what just happened, to get Nick off, I think we need to prove someone else did it. And soon.â
Joe looked around, considering this statement. There were other courthouses in the area. Big, impressive buildings where people came to argue every imaginable legal matterâcrimes, lawsuits, divorces, child
Tim Marquitz
Michelle Fox
John Mortimer
Em Petrova
Brian Moynahan
Gareth P. Jones
Diana Pharaoh Francis
Carolyn Haywood
Barbara Paul
Ian Marter