think I’d invite you down here—I mean, you a priest and all…?” Father Walther realized he should have sensed something was up when Margaret told him his old friend had telephoned. Charlie had never been one for purely social calls. Even those star parties of their adolescence were only forums for the latest crisis in his intellectual or love life. But that particular evening several years back when Charlie had dropped by his rectory the curate had just finished putting in a couple hours in a stuffy confession box and hadn’t been in a mood to inquire too curiously about his friend’s marital state. “So, now you’re starting over.” “That’s right.” They had reached the stretch of beach opposite Charlie’s house. The toddler and mother were gone. “Although I guess I prefer to see it as something more original. Look here,” he added, paying no mind to the icy water lapping at his ankles, “you haven’t said you don’t approve. But you’re wearing the same sanctimonious look you used to put on when we were kids. I know it’s your job to represent the church’s position. But I’m not talking to you as a priest, man.” Charlie’s impatience came as less of a surprise than did his accusation of sanctimoniousness. It had never occurred to young Richard Walther that his adolescent homilies were resented or, worse, not taken seriously. “ I can’t believe one thing with my collar on and another when it’s off. I am your friend, Charlie. But I’m still a priest. I can’t change that.” The waves broke noisily beside them, angry like the flush on Charlie’s face. He had never liked the answers Richard had given him, whether about extraterrestrials (redeemed or prelapsarian?) or sexual morality. He had always insisted on a rational explanation based purely on empirical evidence. But there was never anything logical about his own emotions. The young priest-to-be once watched him pound a dead log to pulp with a tire iron during a fit of frustration brought on by Richard’s insistence that there was indeed a hell. Charlie was one of those who thought Vatican II had rewritten canon law to conform with the spirit of the Declaration of Independence. As it turned out, he had plenty of company in that view, even among clergy. Father Walther had hoped to turn this conversation in a direction very different from the one it had taken. He had hoped to step out of his clerical persona, to become just an ordinary man taking a walk with an old friend. But that was not to be. The world seemed conspiring to keep him in a roman collar, even when he was more than willing to trade it for a sport shirt. The tide was coming in. The eastern horizon was dusty purple. A tanker’s silhouette seemed painted there. “ Look, I didn’t mean to fly off the handle. I understand you can’t say what I did was right. Okay. But I don’t want this to make any difference about your staying on. I promise not to bring the subject up again.” The priest regarded him without rancor. Charlie’s apologies had always been endearing, no matter how outrageous his behavior. “ You bring up any subject you please. We don’t have to agree about everything. God knows we never did in the past. Do you remember all those times you froze my ass off just so you could look at the moons of Mercury?” “ Mercury doesn’t have any moons, Richie. But just wait till it’s dark. With my new reflector I can show you stars millions of light-years away.” “ Do little green men live there?” “ Probably. Statistically, it’s almost a certainty.” “ You used to be more definitive.” By now they were crossing the last dune between the house and the beach. Sylvia waved to them from the second-story balcony where she had set up a charcoal grill. Charlie waved back. So did Father Walther. As they climbed the narrow wooden