great writer, but I hadnât read that much of him. Was I simply trying to contrast myself with her, to make her tastes seem philistine?
âWhat else do you do?â
âI play basketball,â I said. I wasnât sure why Iâd brought this up. Basketball was fine. Iâd played in high school, and at Yale Iâd spent a season on the junior varsity bench, getting beaten up under the boards during practice. I still played pick-up twice a week, but basketball wasnât my life. It wasnât the best way to describe myself.
âYour birth father played basketball.â
âHe did?â
âI used to watch him on the playground after school.â
His image came to me, this man whom for years Iâd thought of as Abraham. Every Abe Iâd met, every Abraham: Iâd examined him as if for a mark, wondering whether he was related to me.
âDid you love him?â I asked.
Her eyes grew moist. âVery much.â
âDidnât he love you?â
âFor a while he did. For a while we both loved each other.â
âBut then?â
She looked sadly at me. âThen we got older.â
What, I wondered, had gone wrong between them? If Iâd been their sonâif Iâd stayed their sonâmaybe Iâd have been able to patch things up.
We went to the counter to get our food and then returned to our table. My birth mother raised her sandwich to her mouth. âI want to know everything about you,â she said. âI want us to catch up.â
That was what I wanted too. So why did I feel compelled to tell her the truth? âWe canât catch up.â
âWhy not?â
âBecause Iâm thirty years old. We can sit here and talk. We can be cordial to each other.â
âBut I want us to be more than cordial.â She reached her hand across the table. For a second I thought she was going to touch me. For a second I wanted her to.
âYouâve never been part of my life,â I said.
âI know that.â She looked downcast. She had her hand on her water glass. Her fingers made slender imprints in the condensation.
I could have told her that I loved her and that I didnât. Why had she brought me into this world? Why had she left me, and why had she waited? Why, right now, had she finally come back, this woman who was sixteen years older than I was, who sat before me after all her troubles and looked young enough to be my sister?
âMrs. Greenââ
âPlease, Ben. Susan.â
âSusan.â
âTell me what youâre thinking.â
âIâm not thinking anything right now.â
âThen tell me the first thing that comes to your mind.â
So I told her that, when we were children, Jonathan would take a picture of me every month. âI used to line up the pictures,â I said. âI was trying to figure out the person I was becoming. I wanted to pinpoint the moment I changed.â
âI like the person youâve become.â
âBut you donât know me.â
âI want to get to know you.â
I wanted to get to know her also. But what if she tried to takeover my life? What would Jenny thinkâJenny who had encouraged me to meet her but who hoped that, in doing so, Iâd move on? I had no idea how you got to know someone when you were trying so hard to do just that. You could fail from all the effort.
Perhaps Iâd grow bored with her. Or maybe sheâd grow bored with me. If weâd met under different circumstances, we might not have had anything to talk about. What could be worse than being bored by your own birth mother?
âHow did you find me?â I finally asked.
âI tracked you down.â
âRight, but how?â
She cupped her hand in front of her face as though she were about to tell me a secret. But I knew no one in the restaurant besides her.
âI hired a private detective,â she said.
âTo follow