boasting.
âReally good!â Rushpaw meowed.
âI was the best,â Hollowpaw declared.
âWhere did you go?â Mistystar put in.
Rushpaw looked surprised. âOh, you know that elderflower bush by the holly tree? Thereâs a clear space under there that is just right for battle training.â
âExcellent,â Mistystar murmured. She was beginning to feel guilty about quizzing them. âReedwhisker saved a mouse for you.â
The apprentices exchanged a glance. âWeâre not hungry right now,â mewed Hollowpaw. âIs it okay if we have it later?â
âYes, of course.â Mistystar turned away but looked back over her shoulder. âAnd well done for working so hard. I know things arenât easy at the moment, but Iâm proud of you for keeping up with your training.â
Rushpaw twitched his tail. âWeâre just doing what any loyal cat would do,â he insisted. âYou can count on us, Mistystar.â
Chapter 8
Keeping her weight balanced over her haunches so that she didnât tip forward and fall in, Mistystar sliced her paw through the water. Her claws sank into the minnowâs narrow body and she flicked it triumphantly onto the rock beside her. The tiny fish flapped for a moment before lying still.
âNicely done!â called a voice, making Mistystar look up in surprise.
Beetlewhisker was watching her from the top of the shore. His brown-and-white fur stood out sharply against the gray stones.
âItâs still not much more than a mouthful,â Mistystar pointed out, glancing down at her catch in disappointment. Reedwhisker had taken a patrol upstream that morning in search of more prey outside the territory, but Mistystar had wanted to check for herself the state of the lake.
âAt least the big fish are coming back!â Beetlewhisker purred.
Mistystar put her head on one side. âThey are?â
Beetlewhisker nodded. âOh, yes. I saw a huge trout yesterday, longer than my tail. Mothwing told me to leave it alone, though.â
âShe did?â
âYes, to give the lake a chance to build up its stocks again. She said we should let the bigger fish build up their numbers and breed again before we start catching them.â
Mistystar felt her mouth fall open. âShe didnât mention this to me.â
Beetlewhisker blinked. âWell, maybe she thought youâd feel the same?â He sounded uncomfortable, and Mistystar felt sorry for challenging him. He wasnât the cat she needed to speak to about this. She stood up and picked up her minnow.
âIâd better add this to the fresh-kill pile,â she meowed. âSee you later, Beetlewhisker.â
She left the warrior standing rather unhappily on the shore, and threaded back through the ferns to the camp. She dropped her fish onto the pile and went to the medicine catsâ den. Mothwing was inside alone, doing something complicated with a heap of leaves.
âWhy did you tell Beetlewhisker not to catch the trout?â Mistystar demanded.
Mothwing looked up. âBecause we want to let the lake recover first,â she meowed. âWhatâs the point of taking all of the big fish as soon as they appear?â
âThat should have been my decision,â Mistystar insisted. She knew she was being stubbornâMothwing had a fair pointâbut she couldnât help feeling that she was being deliberately undermined.
âYou werenât there!â Mothwing pointed out. âAnd Iâm allowed to have an opinion, arenât I?â There was a hint of challenge in her gaze, which made Mistystar bristle even more.
âYou know what? Iâm not sure anymore! Not after lying to the Clan about StarClan!â
âI didnât lie!â Mothwing flashed back.
âBy letting us believe you could be our medicine cat, you did.â
Mothwing stared at her. âAre you saying you donât